Impacts of the China Securities Investor Services Center's Shareholding Exercise on Audit Fees

Sihan Dong

doi:10.54691/bcpbm.v19i.739

Authors

Sihan Dong

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.54691/bcpbm.v19i.739

Keywords:

investor protection, audit fees, the DID model

Abstract

Protecting the legitimate rights and interests of small and medium investors is the basis of the sustainable and healthy development of the capital market. The shareholding exercise pilot policy of China Securities Investor Services Center is a major innovation in the protection mechanism of investors' rights and interests. Taking A-share listed companies from 2013 to 2017 as the sample, this paper constructs a difference-in-difference model (DID) to test the impacts of Investor Services Center's shareholding exercise on audit fees of listed companies. The study finds that the Investor Services Center's shareholding exercise significantly reduces the audit fees. The mechanism test results show that Investor Services Center's shareholding exercise can reduce the audit fees by restraining the level of accrued earnings management and agency costs. Further analyses show that the effect of reducing audit fees by Investor Services Center's shareholding exercise is more obvious in larger enterprises with lower proportion of independent directors. This paper enriches the research related to the protection of small and medium-sized investors, clarifies the impact mechanism of investor protection on audit fees, expands the relevant research on the influencing factors of audit fees, and provides theoretical support and suggestions for the relevant policy formulation of the China Securities Investor Services Center.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Allen, F., Qian, J., and Qian, M. J., “Law, Finance, and Economic Growth in China”, Journal of Financial Economics, 2005, 77(1): 57-116.

Belloc, F., “Law, Finance and Innovation: The Dark Side of Shareholder Protection”, Cambridge Journal of Economics, 2013, 37(4).

Bo Xianhui, Wu Liansheng, “Earnings Management, Information Risk and Audit Opinion”, Auditing Research, 2011(1): pp.90-97.

Cai Chun, Xie Liufang and Ma Kenana, “Managers’ Audit Background, Earnings Management and Abnormal Audit Fees”, Accounting Research, 2015(3): pp. 72-78+95.

Cai Jifu, “Research on the Relationship among Corporate Governance, Audit Risk and Audit Expenses”, Auditing Research, No.3, 2007(3): pp. 65-71.

Cameran Mara, Francis Jere, R., Marra Antonio, and Pettinicchio Angela., “Are There Adverse Consequences of Mandatory Auditor Rotation? Evidence from the Italian Experience”, AUDITING: A Journal of Practice & Theory, 2015, 34(1).

Chen Guojin, Zhao Xiangqin and Lin Hui, “Listed Companies Fraud Punishment and Investor Protection”, Journal of Finance and Economics, 2005(8): pp. 48-58.

Chen, Z., Ke, B., and Yang, Z., “Minority Shareholders’Control Rights and the Quality of Corporate Decisions in Weak Investor Protection Countries: A Natural Experiment from China”, Accounting Review, 2013, 88(4): 1211-1238.

Chemmanur, T. J., Loutskina, E., and Tian, X., “Corporate Venture Capital, Value Creation, and Innovation”, Social Science Electronic Publishing, 2011, 27(8): 2434-2473.

Chen Yunsen, Yuan Wei and Li Zhe, “Effectiveness of Regulatory Minority Shareholders' Right Exercise: Evidence from China Securities Investor Services Center”, Management World, vol. 37, No.6, 2021: pp. 142-158+9+160-162.

Francis, Jr. and Stokes, Dj, “Audit Prices, Product Differentiation, and Scale Economies: Further Evidence from the Australian Market”, Journal of Accounting Research, 1986, 24(2): pp. 383-393.

Ge, W., Ouyang, C., Shi, Z., and Chen Z., “Can a Not-for-profit Minority Institutional Shareholder Make a Big Difference in Corporate Governance? A Quasi-natural Experiment”, Journal of Corporate Finance, 2021(prepublish).

Guo Fei, Yuan Pan and Zhou Jianwei, “Does Complexity of Financial Derivatives Affect Audit Fee? —An Empirical Study on Chinese Listed Commercial Banks”, Accounting Research, 2018(7): pp. 72-78.

Guo Li, “Investor Protection Agency as an Active Shareholder-An Analysis Based on Investor Services Center”, Legal Science, 2019(8): pp. 148-159.

He Huihua and Fang Junxiong, “The Governance Effects of Regulatory Minority Shareholders: Evidence from Financial Restatement”, Management World, 2021, 37(12): pp. 176-195.

Healy, P. M., “The Impact of Bonus Schemeson the Selection of Accounting Principles”, Journal of Accounting and Economics, 1985, 7(4): pp. 85-107.

Hong Jinming, Lin Runyu and Cui Zhikun, “Corporate Risk-taking, Audit Effort and Audit Opinion”, Auditing Research, 2021(3): pp. 96-105.

Hu Guoqiang, Fu Shaozheng and Zhu Jinyu, “Lower hierarchy of Fair Value Measurements Causes Higher Audit Fees? --Evidence from China's Listed Banks”, Accounting Research, 2020(5): pp. 17-29.

Jiang, F., and Kim, K. A., “Corporate Governance in China: A modern Perspective”, Journal of Corporate Finance, 2015, 32(3): pp. 190-216.

Jiang Yihong, Xue Shuang and Cheng Yu, “Determinants of Audit Fees-An Empirical Study Based on the Simunic Model”, Proceedings of the 2nd Session of the 6th Council of China Accounting Society and the 2004 Annual Academic Conference (2), 2004, pp. 78-83.

Ke, B., and Zhang, X.J., “Does Public Enforcement Work in Weak Investor Protection Countries? Evidence from China”, Contemporary Accounting Research, 2021, 38(2).

Kong Dongmin and Liu Shasha, “Minority Shareholder Participation, Corporate Decisions, and Corporate Governance”, Management World, 2017(9): pp. 101-115+188.

Kong Dongmin, Liu Shasha, Li Wenjing and Xing Jingping, “Is Silence Rational? Minority Shareholder Participation, Governance and Investor Protection”, China Economic Quarterly, 2013, 12(1): pp. 1-28.

Li Chen, Liu Wei and You Jiaxing, “Top Management Team Incentive Dispersion and Audit Fees”, Auditing Research, 2021(3), pp. 72-83.

Li Wengui and Yan Han, “Young Executives and Stock Price Crash Risk: Evidence from the Agency conflict view”, Economic Theory and Economic Management, 2020(11): pp. 72-86.

Li Wenjing, Kong Dongmin, Liu Shasha and Xing Jingping, “Can Small and Medium Shareholders Only Take ‘Free Ride’? —Empirical Evidence from Public Shareholders' Online Voting in Shenzhen Stock Exchang”, Journal of Financial Research, 2012(3): pp. 152-165.

Lian Yujun and Liao Junping, “How to Test the Coefficient Difference between Groups after Grouping Regression?”, Journal of Zhengzhou University of Aeronautics, 2017,35(6): pp. 97-109.

Liu Xinming, Wu Haoxiang, Hu Feng and Wang Jiani, “Is Minority Shareholders’ Right Exercise Related to Audit Fees”, Auditing Research, 2021(6): pp. 80-89.

Ma Dongshan and Han Liangliang, “Economic Policy Uncertainty and Audit Fees: A Test of Mediating”, Contemporary Finance & Economics, 2018(11): pp. 111-122.

M. Jian, and T. J. Wong, “Propping through Related Party Transactions”, Review of Accounting Studies, 2010, 15(1).

Shen Huihui, Wu Liansheng and Xiao Zezhong, “Environmental Uncertainty and Audit Opinion: An Investigation Based on Ownership Structure”, Accounting Research, 2010(12): pp. 57-64.

Shen Yifeng, Xu Nianhang and Yang Yi, “Test on the Law Protection of Minority Investors in Different Stages”, Economic Research Journal, 2004(9): pp. 90-100.

Song Jianbo, Wen Wen, Wang Dehong and Shen Wei, “Managerial Power, Internal and External Monitoring and Corporate Risk-taking”, Economic Theory and Economic Management, 2018(6): pp. 96-112.

Song Yunling, Li Zhiwen and Ji Xinwei, “The Punishment Effect of China's Securities Supervision from the Violation of Performance Forecast”, Journal of Financial Research, 2011(6): pp. 136-149.

Sun Guangguo and Li Binghui, “Research on the Theoretical Framework for Evaluating the Effectiveness of Internal Control-Based on the Perspective of Investor Protection”, Research on Financial and Economic Issues, 2014(2): pp. 95-101.

Tang Yuejun and Xu Fei, “Does Independent Director Protect Rights and Interests of Small and Medium Shareholders? ——Research on Voting Mechanisms of Chinese Listed Companies”, Economic Management in China, 2007(7): pp. 42-47.

Wang Ronghua, “Improving Corporation Governance to Enhance Legal Protection of Medium and Small Shareholders' Right in State-owned Enterprise”, Academic Exchange, 2011(2): pp. 52-55.

Wei Minghai, Chen Shenglan and Li Wenjing, “A Review of the Empirical Research on Investor Protection: The Role of Financial Accounting Information”, China Accounting Review, 2007(1): pp. 131-150.

Wei Zhen, “Research on the Correlation between Executive Compensation, Earnings Management and Audit Fees”, On Economic Problems, 2019(2): pp. 116-121+128.

Xin Yu, Huang Xinyi and Ji Beibei, “Nonprofit Organization for Investor Protection and Shareholder Litigation in China: A Multi-Case Study of Securities Litigation Supported by China Securities Investor Services Center”, Management World, 2020, 36(1): pp. 69-87+235.

Xiong Jiacai and tong Daming, “CSISC and Investor Protection: Evidences from Information Disclosure”, Journal of Jiangxi University of Finance and Economics, 2022(1): pp. 32-46.

Zhang Shuhui and Luo mengjia, “Company's Characteristics, the Fair Value and Auditing Fee———An Empirical Analysis based on the Listed Companies in China”, Commercial Research, 2016(1): pp. 108-116.

Zheng Chunmei, Wu Guanglei and Wen Guirong, “Independent Directors of Financial & Accounting and the Quality of Accounting Information under the ESG Framework——Based on Internal Control Effectiveness”, The Theory and Practice of Finance and Economics, 2021, 42(6): pp. 89-95.

Zheng Guojian, Juck Zhang and Xie Sujuan, “Hundred-equity Righteous: The role of the Investor Service Center in Protecting Minority Investors”, Journal of Management Science and Engineering, 2021, 24(9): pp. 38-58.

Zheng Jianming and Sun Shilu, "Tax Administration and Audit Fees——Evidence from the quasi-natural experiment of the ‘Third Phase of Golden Tax Project’", Auditing Research, 2021(4): pp. 43-52.