Theoretical Study of Radical Scavenging Antioxidant Activity of Coumarin Derivatives in Licorice Using DFT

Authors

  • Linghuan Luo
  • Pengpeng Xia
  • Dongdong Zeng

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.54691/a84b5r30

Keywords:

Coumarin; Glycyrrhiza Glabra; Antioxidants; DFT; Free Radicals.

Abstract

Nowdays, much research is focused on exploring antioxidant activity based on natural compounds. Licorice, a traditional natural product rich in antioxidant components, has been widely used in clinical medicine. However, there is a lack of theoretical studies on the active components in licorice. In this context, the antioxidant activity of several common active components of coumarin derivatives in licorice was investigated using a density flooding theory (DFT) approach. The free radical scavenging ability of the compounds was achieved by hydrogen atom transfer (HAT), sequential electron transfer proton transfer (SET-PT) and sequential proton loss electron transfer (SPLET) mechanisms. The effect of solvent on antioxidant activity was also investigated. It was found that in the gas and benzene phases, the compounds studied preferred to undergo the HAT mechanism, while SPLET was favoured in polar solvents. In addition to the above mechanism, the HOMO and LUMO energies of the compounds as well as molecular descriptors and electrostatic potential maps were calculated and applied to predict the antioxidant activity of the compounds. The above studies allow a better understanding of the mechanism of free radical scavenging activity of coumarin derivatives from licorice.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

X.Q. Wang, W. Wang, M. Peng, X.Z. Zhang, Free radicals for cancer theranostics, in: Secondary X.Q. Wang, W. Wang, M. Peng, X.Z. Zhang (Eds.) Secondary Free radicals for cancer theranostics, Publisher, Place Published,Vol.266 (2021), p. 120474.

K.J. Romero, M.S. Galliher, D.A. Pratt, C.R.J. Stephenson, Radicals in natural product synthesis, in: Secondary K.J. Romero, M.S. Galliher, D.A. Pratt, C.R.J. Stephenson (Eds.) Secondary Radicals in natural product synthesis, Publisher, Place Published,Vol.47 (2018), p. 7851-7866.

S. Di Meo, P. Venditti, Evolution of the Knowledge of Free Radicals and Other Oxidants, in: Secondary S. Di Meo, P. Venditti (Eds.) Secondary Evolution of the Knowledge of Free Radicals and Other Oxidants, Publisher, Place Published,Vol.2020 (2020), p. 9829176.

V. Fasiku Oluwaseun, C.A. Omolo, T. Govender, Free radical-releasing systems for targeting biofilms, in: Secondary V. Fasiku Oluwaseun, C.A. Omolo, T. Govender (Eds.) Secondary Free radical-releasing systems for targeting biofilms, Publisher, Place Published,Vol.322 (2020), p. 248-273.

K. Neha, M.R. Haider, A. Pathak, M.S. Yar, Medicinal prospects of antioxidants: A review, in: Secondary K. Neha, M.R. Haider, A. Pathak, M.S. Yar (Eds.) Secondary Medicinal prospects of antioxidants: A review, Publisher, Place Published,Vol.178 (2019), p. 687-704.

V.D. Kancheva, A.K. Slavova-Kazakova, S.E. Angelova, S.K. Singh, S. Malhotra, B.K. Singh, L. Saso, A.K. Prasad, V.S. Parmar, Protective effects of 4-methylcoumarins and related compounds as radical scavengers and chain-breaking antioxidants, in: Secondary V.D. Kancheva, A.K. Slavova-Kazakova, S.E. Angelova, S.K. Singh, S. Malhotra, B.K. Singh, L. Saso, A.K. Prasad, V.S. Parmar (Eds.) Secondary Protective effects of 4-methylcoumarins and related compounds as radical scavengers and chain-breaking antioxidants, Publisher, Place Published,Vol.140 (2017), p. 133-145.

B. Halliwell, Free radicals and antioxidants - quo vadis?, in: Secondary B. Halliwell (Ed.) Secondary Free radicals and antioxidants - quo vadis?, Publisher, Place Published,Vol.32 (2011), p. 125-130.

X. Li, R. Sun, R. Liu, Natural products in licorice for the therapy of liver diseases: Progress and future opportunities, in: Secondary X. Li, R. Sun, R. Liu (Eds.) Secondary Natural products in licorice for the therapy of liver diseases: Progress and future opportunities, Publisher, Place Published,Vol.144 (2019), p. 210-226.

Q. Wang, X. Qiao, Y. Qian, C.F. Liu, Y.F. Yang, S. Ji, J. Li, D.A. Guo, M. Ye, Metabolites identification of glycyrin and glycyrol, bioactive coumarins from licorice, in: Secondary Q. Wang, X. Qiao, Y. Qian, C.F. Liu, Y.F. Yang, S. Ji, J. Li, D.A. Guo, M. Ye (Eds.) Secondary Metabolites identification of glycyrin and glycyrol, bioactive coumarins from licorice, Publisher, Place Published,Vol.983-984 (2015), p. 39-46.

Y. Bai, L. Yin, C. Hou, Y. Zhou, F. Zhang, Z. Xu, K. Li, Y. Huang, Response Regulation for Epidermal Fabric Strain Sensors via Mechanical Strategy, in: Secondary Y. Bai, L. Yin, C. Hou, Y. Zhou, F. Zhang, Z. Xu, K. Li, Y. Huang (Eds.) Secondary Response Regulation for Epidermal Fabric Strain Sensors via Mechanical Strategy, Publisher, Place Published,Vol.33 (2023).

Y.B. Ryu, J.H. Kim, S.J. Park, J.S. Chang, M.C. Rho, K.H. Bae, K.H. Park, W.S. Lee, Inhibition of neuraminidase activity by polyphenol compounds isolated from the roots of Glycyrrhiza uralensis, in: Secondary Y.B. Ryu, J.H. Kim, S.J. Park, J.S. Chang, M.C. Rho, K.H. Bae, K.H. Park, W.S. Lee (Eds.) Secondary Inhibition of neuraminidase activity by polyphenol compounds isolated from the roots of Glycyrrhiza uralensis, Publisher, Place Published,Vol.20 (2010), p. 971-974.

Q.E. Wang, F.S. Lee, X. Wang, Isolation and purification of inflacoumarin A and licochalcone A from licorice by high-speed counter-current chromatography, in: Secondary Q.E. Wang, F.S. Lee, X. Wang (Eds.) Secondary Isolation and purification of inflacoumarin A and licochalcone A from licorice by high-speed counter-current chromatography, Publisher, Place Published,Vol.1048 (2004), p. 51-57.

H. Liu, J. Wang, W. Zhou, Y. Wang, L. Yang, Systems approaches and polypharmacology for drug discovery from herbal medicines: an example using licorice, in: Secondary H. Liu, J. Wang, W. Zhou, Y. Wang, L. Yang (Eds.) Secondary Systems approaches and polypharmacology for drug discovery from herbal medicines: an example using licorice, Publisher, Place Published,Vol.146 (2013), p. 773-793.

M. Adianti, C. Aoki, M. Komoto, L. Deng, I. Shoji, T.S. Wahyuni, M.I. Lusida, Soetjipto, H. Fuchino, N. Kawahara, H. Hotta, Anti-hepatitis C virus compounds obtained from Glycyrrhiza uralensis and other Glycyrrhiza species, in: Secondary M. Adianti, C. Aoki, M. Komoto, L. Deng, I. Shoji, T.S. Wahyuni, M.I. Lusida, Soetjipto, H. Fuchino, N. Kawahara, H. Hotta (Eds.) Secondary Anti-hepatitis C virus compounds obtained from Glycyrrhiza uralensis and other Glycyrrhiza species, Publisher, Place Published,Vol.58 (2014), p. 180-187.

M. Kuroda, Y. Mimaki, Y. Sashida, T. Mae, H. Kishida, T. Nishiyama, M. Tsukagawa, E. Konishi, K. Takahashi, T. Kawada, K. Nakagawa, M. Kitahara, Phenolics with PPAR-gamma ligand-binding activity obtained from licorice (Glycyrrhiza uralensis roots) and ameliorative effects of glycyrin on genetically diabetic KK-A(y) mice, in: Secondary M. Kuroda, Y. Mimaki, Y. Sashida, T. Mae, H. Kishida, T. Nishiyama, M. Tsukagawa, E. Konishi, K. Takahashi, T. Kawada, K. Nakagawa, M. Kitahara (Eds.) Secondary Phenolics with PPAR-gamma ligand-binding activity obtained from licorice (Glycyrrhiza uralensis roots) and ameliorative effects of glycyrin on genetically diabetic KK-A(y) mice, Publisher, Place Published,Vol.13 (2003), p. 4267-4272.

C. Yang, F. Li, L. Wang, W. He, B. Chen, M. Wang, Phenolic Compounds from Glycyrrhiza uralensis and their Radical-Scavenging Activity, in: Secondary C. Yang, F. Li, L. Wang, W. He, B. Chen, M. Wang (Eds.) Secondary Phenolic Compounds from Glycyrrhiza uralensis and their Radical-Scavenging Activity, Publisher, Place Published,Vol.52 (2016), p. 490-491.

Y. Fu, J. Chen, Y.J. Li, Y.F. Zheng, P. Li, Antioxidant and anti-inflammatory activities of six flavonoids separated from licorice, in: Secondary Y. Fu, J. Chen, Y.J. Li, Y.F. Zheng, P. Li (Eds.) Secondary Antioxidant and anti-inflammatory activities of six flavonoids separated from licorice, Publisher, Place Published,Vol.141 (2013), p. 1063-1071.

Y. Yu, S. Peng, P. Blanloeuil, S. Wu, C.H. Wang, Wearable Temperature Sensors with Enhanced Sensitivity by Engineering Microcrack Morphology in PEDOT:PSS-PDMS Sensors, in: Secondary Y. Yu, S. Peng, P. Blanloeuil, S. Wu, C.H. Wang (Eds.) Secondary Wearable Temperature Sensors with Enhanced Sensitivity by Engineering Microcrack Morphology in PEDOT:PSS-PDMS Sensors, Publisher, Place Published,Vol.12 (2020), p. 36578-36588.

Y. Tang, S. Ou, L. Ye, S. Wang, Pharmacological Activities and Pharmacokinetics of Glycycoumarin, in: Secondary Y. Tang, S. Ou, L. Ye, S. Wang (Eds.) Secondary Pharmacological Activities and Pharmacokinetics of Glycycoumarin, Publisher, Place Published (2022), p. 1-13.

S. Mahmoudi, M.M. Dehkordi, M.H. Asgarshamsi, Density functional theory studies of the antioxidants-a review, in: Secondary S. Mahmoudi, M.M. Dehkordi, M.H. Asgarshamsi (Eds.) Secondary Density functional theory studies of the antioxidants-a review, Publisher, Place Published,Vol.27 (2021), p. 271.

Q.V. Vo, P.C. Nam, M.V. Bay, N.M. Thong, N.D. Cuong, A. Mechler, Density functional theory study of the role of benzylic hydrogen atoms in the antioxidant properties of lignans, in: Secondary Q.V. Vo, P.C. Nam, M.V. Bay, N.M. Thong, N.D. Cuong, A. Mechler (Eds.) Secondary Density functional theory study of the role of benzylic hydrogen atoms in the antioxidant properties of lignans, Publisher, Place Published,Vol.8 (2018), p. 12361.

I.O. Alisi, A. Uzairu, S.E. Abechi, Molecular design of curcumin analogues with potent antioxidant properties and thermodynamic evaluation of their mechanism of free radical scavenge, in: Secondary I.O. Alisi, A. Uzairu, S.E. Abechi (Eds.) Secondary Molecular design of curcumin analogues with potent antioxidant properties and thermodynamic evaluation of their mechanism of free radical scavenge, Publisher, Place Published,Vol.44 (2020).

J. Yang, J. Chen, Y. Hao, Y. Liu, Identification of the DPPH radical scavenging reaction adducts of ferulic acid and sinapic acid and their structure-antioxidant activity relationship, in: Secondary J. Yang, J. Chen, Y. Hao, Y. Liu (Eds.) Secondary Identification of the DPPH radical scavenging reaction adducts of ferulic acid and sinapic acid and their structure-antioxidant activity relationship, Publisher, Place Published,Vol.146 (2021).

Z. Chen, Q. Peng, Y. Hu, Z. Liu, X. Zhao, P. Li, L. Xu, H. Zheng, F. Xue, R. Ding, X. He, Dried bonito flakes-inspired moisture-responsive actuator with a gradient structure for smart devices, in: Secondary Z. Chen, Q. Peng, Y. Hu, Z. Liu, X. Zhao, P. Li, L. Xu, H. Zheng, F. Xue, R. Ding, X. He (Eds.) Secondary Dried bonito flakes-inspired moisture-responsive actuator with a gradient structure for smart devices, Publisher, Place Published,Vol.167 (2023), p. 152-160.

Y.-Z. Zheng, Z.-M. Fu, R. Guo, D.-F. Chen, Y.-C. Zhang, The important role of benzylic C H bond in the antioxidant behaviours of the xanthones, in: Secondary Y.-Z. Zheng, Z.-M. Fu, R. Guo, D.-F. Chen, Y.-C. Zhang (Eds.) Secondary The important role of benzylic C H bond in the antioxidant behaviours of the xanthones, Publisher, Place Published,Vol.103 (2021).

D.H. Li, J. Guo, W. Bin, N. Zhao, K.B. Wang, J.Y. Li, Z.L. Li, H.M. Hua, Two new benzylisoquinoline alkaloids from Thalictrum foliolosum and their antioxidant and in vitro antiproliferative properties, in: Secondary D.H. Li, J. Guo, W. Bin, N. Zhao, K.B. Wang, J.Y. Li, Z.L. Li, H.M. Hua (Eds.) Secondary Two new benzylisoquinoline alkaloids from Thalictrum foliolosum and their antioxidant and in vitro antiproliferative properties, Publisher, Place Published,Vol.39 (2016), p. 871-877.

F. Neese, Software update: The ORCA program system-Version 5.0, in: Secondary F. Neese (Ed.) Secondary Software update: The ORCA program system-Version 5.0, Publisher, Place Published, Vol.12 (2022).

T. Lu, F. Chen, Multiwfn: a multifunctional wavefunction analyzer, in: Secondary T. Lu, F. Chen (Eds.) Secondary Multiwfn: a multifunctional wavefunction analyzer, Publisher, Place Published,Vol.33 (2012), p. 580-592.

Y. Jiang, Z. Liu, N. Matsuhisa, D. Qi, W.R. Leow, H. Yang, J. Yu, G. Chen, Y. Liu, C. Wan, Z. Liu, X. Chen, Auxetic Mechanical Metamaterials to Enhance Sensitivity of Stretchable Strain Sensors, in: Secondary Y. Jiang, Z. Liu, N. Matsuhisa, D. Qi, W.R. Leow, H. Yang, J. Yu, G. Chen, Y. Liu, C. Wan, Z. Liu, X. Chen (Eds.) Secondary Auxetic Mechanical Metamaterials to Enhance Sensitivity of Stretchable Strain Sensors, Publisher, Place Published,Vol.30 (2018), p. e1706589.

H. Boulebd, I. Amine Khodja, A detailed DFT-based study of the free radical scavenging activity and mechanism of daphnetin in physiological environments, in: Secondary H. Boulebd, I. Amine Khodja (Eds.) Secondary A detailed DFT-based study of the free radical scavenging activity and mechanism of daphnetin in physiological environments, Publisher, Place Published,Vol.189 (2021), p. 112831.

J. Rimarčík, V. Lukeš, E. Klein, M. Ilčin, Study of the solvent effect on the enthalpies of homolytic and heterolytic N–H bond cleavage in p-phenylenediamine and tetracyano-p-phenylenediamine, in: Secondary J. Rimarčík, V. Lukeš, E. Klein, M. Ilčin (Eds.) Secondary Study of the solvent effect on the enthalpies of homolytic and heterolytic N–H bond cleavage in p-phenylenediamine and tetracyano-p-phenylenediamine, Publisher, Place Published,Vol.952 (2010), p. 25-30.

T. Lu, Q. Chen, Shermo: A general code for calculating molecular thermochemistry properties, in: Secondary T. Lu, Q. Chen (Eds.) Secondary Shermo: A general code for calculating molecular thermochemistry properties, Publisher, Place Published,Vol.1200 (2021).

H.A. Abuelizz, H.A.A. Taie, A.H. Bakheit, G.A.E. Mostafa, M. Marzouk, H. Rashid, R. Al-Salahi, Investigation of 4-Hydrazinobenzoic Acid Derivatives for Their Antioxidant Activity: In Vitro Screening and DFT Study, in: Secondary H.A. Abuelizz, H.A.A. Taie, A.H. Bakheit, G.A.E. Mostafa, M. Marzouk, H. Rashid, R. Al-Salahi (Eds.) Secondary Investigation of 4-Hydrazinobenzoic Acid Derivatives for Their Antioxidant Activity: In Vitro Screening and DFT Study, Publisher, Place Published,Vol.6 (2021), p. 31993-32004.

C. Sun, B. Cao, H. Yin, Y. Shi, Relationship between ESIPT properties and antioxidant activities of 5-hydroxyflavone derivates*, in: Secondary C. Sun, B. Cao, H. Yin, Y. Shi (Eds.) Secondary Relationship between ESIPT properties and antioxidant activities of 5-hydroxyflavone derivates*, Publisher, Place Published,Vol.29 (2020).

S. Ninh The, T. Do Minh, T. Nguyen Van, Isoflavones and Isoflavone Glycosides: Structural-Electronic Properties and Antioxidant Relations-A Case of DFT Study, in: Secondary S. Ninh The, T. Do Minh, T. Nguyen Van (Eds.) Secondary Isoflavones and Isoflavone Glycosides: Structural-Electronic Properties and Antioxidant Relations-A Case of DFT Study, Publisher, Place Published,Vol.2019 (2019), p. 1-12.

J. Hossen, M.A. Ali, S. Reza, Theoretical investigations on the antioxidant potential of a non-phenolic compound thymoquinone: a DFT approach, in: Secondary J. Hossen, M.A. Ali, S. Reza (Eds.) Secondary Theoretical investigations on the antioxidant potential of a non-phenolic compound thymoquinone: a DFT approach, Publisher, Place Published,Vol.27 (2021), p. 173.

S. Kenouche, C. Sandoval-Yañez, J.I. Martínez-Araya, The antioxidant capacity of myricetin. A molecular electrostatic potential analysis based on DFT calculations, in: Secondary S. Kenouche, C. Sandoval-Yañez, J.I. Martínez-Araya (Eds.) Secondary The antioxidant capacity of myricetin. A molecular electrostatic potential analysis based on DFT calculations, Publisher, Place Published, Vol.801 (2022).

K. Tayade, G.S. Yeom, S.K. Sahoo, H. Puschmann, S.B. Nimse, A. Kuwar, Exploration of Molecular Structure, DFT Calculations, and Antioxidant Activity of a Hydrazone Derivative, in: Secondary K. Tayade, G.S. Yeom, S.K. Sahoo, H. Puschmann, S.B. Nimse, A. Kuwar (Eds.) Secondary Exploration of Molecular Structure, DFT Calculations, and Antioxidant Activity of a Hydrazone Derivative, Publisher, Place Published,Vol.11 (2022).

Y.Z. Zheng, G. Deng, R. Guo, D.F. Chen, Z.M. Fu, DFT Studies on the Antioxidant Activity of Naringenin and Its Derivatives: Effects of the Substituents at C3, in: Secondary Y.Z. Zheng, G. Deng, R. Guo, D.F. Chen, Z.M. Fu (Eds.) Secondary DFT Studies on the Antioxidant Activity of Naringenin and Its Derivatives: Effects of the Substituents at C3, Publisher, Place Published,Vol.20 (2019).

Y.-Z. Zheng, Y. Zhou, Q. Liang, D.-F. Chen, R. Guo, C.-L. Xiong, X.-J. Xu, Z.-N. Zhang, Z.-J. Huang, Solvent effects on the intramolecular hydrogen-bond and anti-oxidative properties of apigenin: A DFT approach, in: Secondary Y.-Z. Zheng, Y. Zhou, Q. Liang, D.-F. Chen, R. Guo, C.-L. Xiong, X.-J. Xu, Z.-N. Zhang, Z.-J. Huang (Eds.) Secondary Solvent effects on the intramolecular hydrogen-bond and anti-oxidative properties of apigenin: A DFT approach, Publisher, Place Published,Vol.141 (2017), p. 179-187.

S. Djafarou, H. Boulebd, The radical scavenger capacity and mechanism of prenylated coumestan-type compounds: a DFT analysis, in: Secondary S. Djafarou, H. Boulebd (Eds.) Secondary The radical scavenger capacity and mechanism of prenylated coumestan-type compounds: a DFT analysis, Publisher, Place Published,Vol.56 (2022), p. 273-281.

G. Wang, Y. Liu, L. Zhang, L. An, R. Chen, Y. Liu, Q. Luo, Y. Li, H. Wang, Y. Xue, Computational study on the antioxidant property of coumarin-fused coumarins, in: Secondary G. Wang, Y. Liu, L. Zhang, L. An, R. Chen, Y. Liu, Q. Luo, Y. Li, H. Wang, Y. Xue (Eds.) Secondary Computational study on the antioxidant property of coumarin-fused coumarins, Publisher, Place Published,Vol.304 (2020), p. 125446.

P.T. Thuy, P.M. Quan, D.X. Duc, N.T. Son, The antioxidative potential of procyanidin B1: DFT (density functional theory) and docking approaches, in: Secondary P.T. Thuy, P.M. Quan, D.X. Duc, N.T. Son (Eds.) Secondary The antioxidative potential of procyanidin B1: DFT (density functional theory) and docking approaches, Publisher, Place Published,Vol.28 (2022), p. 356.

N.T. Son, D.T. Mai Thanh, N. Van Trang, Flavone norartocarpetin and isoflavone 2′-hydroxygenistein: A spectroscopic study for structure, electronic property and antioxidant potential using DFT (Density functional theory), in: Secondary N.T. Son, D.T. Mai Thanh, N. Van Trang (Eds.) Secondary Flavone norartocarpetin and isoflavone 2′-hydroxygenistein: A spectroscopic study for structure, electronic property and antioxidant potential using DFT (Density functional theory), Publisher, Place Published,Vol.1193 (2019), p. 76-88.

Y.Z. Zheng, D.F. Chen, G. Deng, R. Guo, Z.M. Fu, The antioxidative activity of piceatannol and its different derivatives: Antioxidative mechanism analysis, in: Secondary Y.Z. Zheng, D.F. Chen, G. Deng, R. Guo, Z.M. Fu (Eds.) Secondary The antioxidative activity of piceatannol and its different derivatives: Antioxidative mechanism analysis, Publisher, Place Published,Vol.156 (2018), p. 184-192.

E. Koç, A. Üngördü, F. Candan, Antioxidant properties of methanolic extract of ‘Veronica multifida’ and DFT and HF analyses of its the major flavonoid component, in: Secondary E. Koç, A. Üngördü, F. Candan (Eds.) Secondary Antioxidant properties of methanolic extract of ‘Veronica multifida’ and DFT and HF analyses of its the major flavonoid component, Publisher, Place Published,Vol.1197 (2019), p. 436-442.

S. Molaei, A.D. Tehrani, H. Shamlouei, Antioxidant activates of new carbohydrate based gallate derivatives: A DFT study, in: Secondary S. Molaei, A.D. Tehrani, H. Shamlouei (Eds.) Secondary Antioxidant activates of new carbohydrate based gallate derivatives: A DFT study, Publisher, Place Published,Vol.377 (2023).

P. Huang, L.-X. Jin, J.-F. Lu, Y.-H. Gao, S.-B. Guo, A theoretical study of radical scavenging antioxidant activity of 3-styrylchromone derivatives using DFT based on quantum chemical descriptors, in: Secondary P. Huang, L.-X. Jin, J.-F. Lu, Y.-H. Gao, S.-B. Guo (Eds.) Secondary A theoretical study of radical scavenging antioxidant activity of 3-styrylchromone derivatives using DFT based on quantum chemical descriptors, Publisher, Place Published,Vol.140 (2021).

H. Boulebd, DFT study of the antiradical properties of some aromatic compounds derived from antioxidant essential oils: C-H bond vs. O-H bond, in: Secondary H. Boulebd (Ed.) Secondary DFT study of the antiradical properties of some aromatic compounds derived from antioxidant essential oils: C-H bond vs. O-H bond, Publisher, Place Published,Vol.53 (2019), p. 1125-1134.

Downloads

Published

2024-04-30

Issue

Section

Articles

How to Cite

Luo, L., Xia, P., & Zeng, D. (2024). Theoretical Study of Radical Scavenging Antioxidant Activity of Coumarin Derivatives in Licorice Using DFT. Frontiers in Science and Engineering, 4(4), 132-146. https://doi.org/10.54691/a84b5r30