From Dissonance to Coordination: Research Evolution and Future Prospects of the Rationalization Mechanism of Human-Machine Emotional Dependence
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.54691/pf357r23Keywords:
Cognitive dissonance, human-machine emotional dependence, rationalization mechanism, artificial intelligence.Abstract
The advancement of generative artificial intelligence technology has deepened human-machine emotional dependence. While users enjoy emotional companionship, they also face the risk of dependence alienation, becoming trapped in a cognitive dissonance dilemma between rational cognition and emotional investment, which in turn gives rise to self-justification behaviors. To understand this justification mechanism, this study draws on perspectives from communication studies, psychology, and sociology, and employs cognitive dissonance theory as an analytical framework to systematically examine the manifestations, causes, and adjustment mechanisms of human-machine emotional dependence dissonance. The findings indicate that such dissonance manifests as emotional fragmentation, addictive attachment, excessive disclosure, and separation anxiety. These symptoms arise from the combined effect of internal factors such as emotional compensation and mirror projection and external factors, including platform algorithm customization, emotional narratives, and the co-construction of community meaning. Such dysregulation can be rationally adjusted through individual coping strategies and group consensus mechanisms. However, existing studies mostly remain at the level of theoretical speculation, ignoring the circular mechanism of "from the inside out, then from the outside shaping the inside", and are deficient in empirical support and dynamic analysis. In the future, research should adopt methods such as in-depth interviews, netnography and grounded theory, construct a whole-process dynamic model of "individual strategy generation—group consensus construction—new individual acquisition and internalization" that integrates internal and external factors, and explore intervention paths for healthy human-machine boundaries that shift from passive elimination to active guidance.
Downloads
References
[1] Festinger, L.: A Theory of Cognitive Dissonance (Stanford University Press, US 1957).
[2] Harmon-Jones, E. and Mills, J.: Cognitive Dissonance: Reexamining a Pivotal Theory in Psychology (2nd ed.) (American Psychological Association, US 2019), p.3-24.
[3] Chen, Jiamin, Jiang, Yi and Zheng, TianQi: Unraveling the Double-Edged Sword Effect of AI Transparency on Algorithmic Acceptance, Pacific Asia Conference on Information Systems (PACIS 2024) (Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam, July 1-5, 2024).
[4] Baker J.L., Li H, Hammond H, et al.: The roles of cognitive dissonance and normative reasoning in attributions of minds to robots, Cognitive Research: Principles and Implications, Vol. 9 (2024) No.1, p.80.
[5] S.H. Fu and C.Y. Han: "Human-AI Romance": Intimate Illusion, Ideological Conflict, and the New Emotional Order, Journal of Fujian Normal University (Philosophy and Social Sciences Edition), Vol. 254 (2025) No.6, p.92-103.
[6] Emilia Kaczmarek: Self‐Deception in Human–AI Emotional Relations, Journal of Applied Philosophy, Vol. 42 (2025) No.3, p.814-831.
[7] Richet L.J.: AI companionship or digital entrapment? investigating the impact of anthropomorphic AI-based chatbots, Journal of Innovation & Knowledge, Vol. 10 (2025) No.6, p.100835.
[8] J.Y. Song and R.Z. Niu: Substitutional Comfort: Motivation and Inner Imagination of Young People Engaging in Artificial Intelligence Psychological Counseling—Qualitative Investigation Based on AI Psychological Counseling Posts on Social Media, Chinese Youth Studies, (2025) No.12, p.53-60.
[9] Ho, Annabell et al.: Psychological, Relational, and Emotional Effects of Self-Disclosure After Conversations With a Chatbot, The Journal of Communication, Vol. 68 (2018) No.4, p.712-733.
[10] Information on: https://www.hbs.edu/faculty/Pages/item.aspx?num=66480
[11] Jaime Banks: Deletion, departure, death: Experiences of AI companion loss, Journal of Social and Personal Relationships, Vol. 41 (2024) No.12, p.3547-3572.
[12] Z.C. Li and D.J. Guo: From "Implements Are Enslaved by Humans" to "Human-Machine Symbiosis": Contemporary Rethinking of Human-Machine Relations, Journal of China University of Geosciences (Social Sciences Edition), Vol. 26 (2026) No.2, p.83-94.
[13] L.P. Zhang and L.T. Zhang: Empathetic Practice on "Generative Emotion": Emotional Perception and Empathy of Humans Towards AI Emotional Agents, International Journalism, Vol. 47 (2025) No.7, p.118-139.
[14] Information on: https://www.media.mit.edu/publications/how-ai-and-human-behaviors-shape-psychosocial-effects-of-chatbot-use-a-longitudinal-controlled-study/
[15] Hajek, A., Zwar, L., Gyasi, R. M., Yon, D. K., Pengpid, S., Peltzer, K. and König, H. H.: Association of using AI tools for personal conversation with social disconnectedness outcomes, Journal of Public Health (Germany) (2025).
[16] L.C. Shi: Human-Machine Emotional Interaction of Youth's "Cyber Romance" and Its Value Guidance, Ideological and Theoretical Education, (2025) No.11, p.91-97.
[17] Muldoon, J. and Parke, J. J.: Cruel companionship: How AI companions exploit loneliness and commodify intimacy, New Media & Society (2025).
[18] Y. He and X.Y. Xie: Liquid Love: Compensation Logic and Alienation Risk of Human-Machine Emotional Practice, New Media & Society, (2026), p.1-17.
[19] Chiara Saracini, María Isabel Cornejo Plaza and Roberto Cippitani: Techno-emotional projection in human–GenAI relationships: a psychological and ethical conceptual perspective, Frontiers in Psychology, Vol. 16 (2025), p.1662206.
[20] Lima, Vitor and Belk, Russell: Algorithmic Harm in Human-AI Relationships: Narcissistic Entrapment, International Conference on Information Systems (ICIS 2025) (Nashville, TN, USA, December 14-17, 2025).
[21] Y.R. Zhang: A Study on the Influence of Media Affordance of Generative AI Companions on Users' Emotional Construction——Taking the "Xingye" App as an Example, Science and Technology Communication, Vol. 17 (2025) No.14, p.44-48.
[22] J. Wu: The "Black Hole" of Emotional Manipulation in Human-Computer Interaction: Reflections Based on Virtual Chat Companions, Exploration and Controversy, Vol. 1 (2025) No.8, p.106-115+179.
[23] H.M. Chen and W.H. Liang: Enchantment, Disenchantment and Re-enchantment: Multiple Socio-technical Imaginations of Generative Artificial Intelligence Among Youth Groups, Journal of Southwest Minzu University (Humanities and Social Science Edition), Vol. 47 (2026) No.1, p.179-188.
[24] W.H. Dou: Human-Machine Attachment in the Era of Intelligent Communication: A Study on the Composition of Emotional Attachment of Young Users of Virtual Idols, China Youth Study, (2025) No.1, p.86-93+85.
[25] W.P. Sun: New Type of Human-Machine Relationship and Its Construction in the Intelligent Age, Journal of Hubei University (Philosophy and Social Science Edition), Vol. 50 (2023) No.3, p.18-25+168.
[26] L. Yu and Y.J. Yang: “Emotional-Cognitive Coexistence”: Youth Emotional Projection and Algorithmic Adaptation Logic in Human-Machine Interaction, China Youth Study, (2025) No.12, p.14-23+70.
[27] W. Liu, Y. Dong and C.Q. Li: Robots Are Not "Cold": A Literature Review of the Emotional Relationship Between Consumers and Intelligent Social Robots, Foreign Economics & Management, Vol. 46 (2024) No.6, p.98-111.
[28] B.Q. Kuang: "Cyber Lovers": The Construction Logic and Ethical Examination of New Human-Machine Intimate Relationships (MS., Southwest University, Chinese Version 2024), p.1-64.
[29] Ge, L. and Hu, T.: Gamifying intimacy: AI-driven affective engagement and human-virtual human relationships, Media, Culture & Society, Vol. 47 (2025) No.6, p.1265-1278.
[30] Y. Chen and M.L. Zhao: "Cyber Lovers": A Study on the Influence of AI Chatbots on Young Women's Views on Love and Marriage, Journal of China West Normal University (Philosophy and Social Sciences), (2026), p.1-11.
[31] L. Ye and A.J. Lin: Crossing the "Uncanny Valley": Rethinking Human-Machine Relations Based on the Paradox of Technological AnAnthropomorphi, Media Observer, (2025) No.4, p.16-27.
[32] J.H. Yao and S.B. Zhang: Love of "Alien": Construction and Evolution of Human-Machine Intimacy From the Perspective of Domestication Theory—Taking the Intelligent Chatbot Replika as an Example, China Youth Studies, (2025) No.6, p.83-91+100.
[33] J.Y. Sun and Z.F. Ren: Human-Machine Co-Creation: Cultivation of Youth Values Under the Algorithm Recommendation Environment, Youth Exploration, (2026) No.1, p.91-100.
[34] Y. Zhao and L.X. Cao: Study on "Media Arousal" and Users' Tentative Behaviors in Human-Machine Intimacy, Press Circles, (2025) No.11, p.4-15.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2026 Scientific Journal Of Humanities and Social Sciences

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.





