Analysis of Research Hotspots and Development Trend of Domestic Manned/Unmanned System Cooperative Warfare Issues

Jianyong Weng; Qiwu Wu; Xiaohang Lu

doi:10.6911/WSRJ.202501_11(1).0007

Authors

Jianyong Weng
Qiwu Wu
Xiaohang Lu

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.6911/WSRJ.202501_11(1).0007

Keywords:

Manned/unmanned; Cooperative operations; Citespace; Tableau.

Abstract

In order to fully understand the current comprehensive development of the manned/unmanned system cooperative operation (MUMT) problem, the current domestic research in this field is analyzed by using Citespace and Tableau, with a view to supporting the prediction of the future development trend. It is found that, against the background of rapid development of informatization, unmanned and intelligentization, the research on issues related to manned/unmanned coordinated warfare is becoming more and more common, with the space ranging from the air to the sea, from the surface to the underwater and then to the ground, and the outreach of the research content is also becoming more and more rich, which mainly involves the planning of operational missions, generation of operational capabilities, operational technology requirements, and exploration of the operational modes, and so on. In the future, manned/unmanned combat will be the main mode of war, which has been confirmed by the Russian-Ukrainian war, but how to conduct more systematic and comprehensive in-depth research and precise and efficient deepening of the application will be directly related to the victory or defeat of the future war.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

[1] SUN Linhui,LI Xun. Research status, hotspots and development trend of international manned/unmanned aircraft coordinated combat - BiblioShiny visualization and analysis based on WoS data from 2000-2022[J]. Sino-Arab Science and Technology Forum (in Chinese and English), 2023, (05):48-58.

[2] WU Qiwu, LIU Jiaqi, WU Husheng. Analysis of research hotspots and development trend of unmanned aerial vehicle (UAV) cluster mission planning [J]. Journal of Weapons and Equipment Engineering, 2023, 44(5): 294-302.

[3] Zhang Honghong, Li Wenhua, Zheng Jiayi, et al. Manned/unmanned aircraft cooperative operations: concepts, technologies and challenges [J]. Journal of Aeronautics, 2024, 45(15):029653.

[4] JIANG Peng, WANG Rui, ZHENG Lihui, et al. Research status and development trend of foreign manned/unmanned aircraft cooperative warfare[J]. Military Automation,2023,42(03):84-89.

[5] ZHANG Lu, DANG Jing, SHAO Zhengtu. Analysis and revelation of Russian army's manned aircraft and unmanned aircraft cooperative warfare[J]. Ship Electronic Countermeasures,2022,45(03):1-6.DOI:10.16426/j.cnki.jcdzdk.2022.03.001.

[6] ZHANG Lu, SHAO Zhengtu, WENG Chengxiang, et al. Research on the utilization and key technology of U.S. Army's have/UAV cooperative operation[J]. Tactical Missile Technology, 2022, (06): 128-137.DOI:10.16358/j.issn.1009-1300.20220021.

[7] LI Song, ZHANG Chunhua, SUN Yufei, et al. Study on the Development of Cross-domain Cooperative Warfare Capability of U.S. Army Unmanned Systems[J]. China Academy of Electronic Science and Technology

[8] li wen,chen jian. Research review and outlook of manned aircraft/unmanned aircraft hybrid formation cooperative operation [J]. Aerospace Control, 2017, 35 (03): 90-96. DOI:10.16804/j.cnki.issn1006-3242.2017.03.017.

[9] Chen Lingsong, Ji Simei, Guo Mei. Research on task allocation method of have/UAV cooperative operation[J]. Flying Missile 2015.(07):36-38.DOI:10.16338/j.issn.1009-1319.2015.07.08.

[10] Zhang Xinwei. A hybrid manned/unmanned aircraft formation cooperative task allocation method[J]. Modern Navigation,2017,8(06):417-421.

[11] ZHOU Wei-Qiang,SU Yao. Design and research of interoperability model for manned/unmanned aircraft cooperative operations[C]//China Command and Control Society. Proceedings of the Ninth China Command and Control Conference. Communication Branch, 20th Research Institute of China Electronics Technology Group Corporation;,2021:6.DOI:10.26914/c.cnkihy.2021.011206.

[12] Hu Yue. Research on manned/unmanned aircraft cooperative combat task allocation and trajectory planning [D]. Nanjing University of Aeronautics and Astronautics, 2020.DOI:10.27239/d.cnki.gnhhu.2020.000168.

[13] LIU Hongqiang, WEI Xianzhi, FU Zhaowang, et al. Research on task allocation method of manned aircraft/unmanned aircraft formation coordinated attack [J]. Electro-Optics and Control, 2013, 20(06): 16-19.

[14] T.D. Chen. Research on key technology of combat mission planning for manned/unmanned detachment [D]. Nanjing University of Science and Technology, 2023.DOI:10.27241/d.cnki.gnjgu.2023.000028.

[15] ZHAO Tuo,ZHANG Xianjian,HUANG Jian. Manned/unmanned aircraft cooperative air combat mission planning technology[J]. Firepower and Command and Control,2024,49(02):1-10.

[16] ZHANG Jia,LIU Qingping,XIN Bin. Research on mission understanding of manned/unmanned system cooperative operation[J]. Firepower and Command and Control,2022,47(10):52-58.

[17] ZHAO Xiaoru, YANG Renong, YAN Mengda, et al. Modeling of manned-unmanned cooperative combat architecture based on combat management[J]. Air Force Engineering University

[18] DING Lianghui,TIAN Jiaming,ZHANG Yate,et al. Design of manned/unmanned cooperative amphibious landing combat architecture based on DoDAF[C]//Chinese Command and Control Society.2023 Proceedings of the Seventh National Conference on Cluster Intelligence and Cooperative Control. Shanghai Jiao Tong University;China Aviation Radio Electronics Research Institute;Shanghai Institute of Electromechanical Engineering;, 2023:8.DOI:10.26914/c.cnkihy.2023.120073.

[19] JANG Yucheng,GUO Kilian. Design of manned aircraft/unmanned aircraft cooperative effect evaluation model[J]. Military Operations and Systems Engineering,2016,30(03):28-31.

[20] SHI FENGCHA, BAI JIANGBO, LU Di. Analysis of foreign army with/without manned grouping technology[J]. Command Control and Simulation,2024,46(01):30-36.

[21] Huang Songhua. Key Technology Analysis of Manned/Unmanned Distributed Combat System[C]//China Command and Control Society. Proceedings of the Sixth China Command and Control Conference (Previous Volume). Key Laboratory of Information System Engineering;,2018:5.

[22] Jieyong Zhang, Eddie Zhong, Peng Sun, Jinzhe Ma. Manned/unmanned aircraft cooperative operation command and control system technology [J]. Journal of Command and Control, 2021, 7(2): 203-214

[23] WANG Xun,YAO Peiyang,TAI Dongdong. On manned aircraft/unmanned aircraft formation cooperative combat decision making[J]. Computer Simulation,2015,32(09):128-132.

[24] Jun Chen, Xinwei Zhang, Jia Xu, et al. Finite-intervention cooperative decision-making for manned/unmanned aircraft hybrid formation [J]. Journal of Aviation, 2015, 36(11):365236- 65.

[25] Yang Yulong. Research on manned aircraft/unmanned aircraft cooperative operation mode and key technology[C]// China Aviation Society. Proceedings of the Fifth China Aviation Science and Technology Conference. China Aviation Radio Electronics Research.

[26] SHI Guoqing,WU Fan,ZHANG Lin,et al. Analysis of manned/unmanned aircraft cooperative combat capability based on combined empowerment method[J]. Firepower and Command and Control,2019,44(04):87-91.

[27] Bao Zhan, Wang Shuwen. Research on the generation problem of manned/unmanned aircraft cooperative combat capability[J]. National Defense Science and Technology,2017,38(03):76-79.DOI:10.13943/j.issn1671-4547.2017.03.12.

[28] HUANG Songhua,ZHANG Zhaochen. Research on the Development of Manned/Unmanned Distributed Combat System of U.S. Army[C]// China Command and Control Society. Proceedings of the Sixth China Command and Control Conference (Previous Volume). Key Laboratory of Information System Engineering;,2018:5.

[29] ZHANG Yongli,SUN Zhishui,ZHOU Rongkun. Evaluation of manned aircraft/unmanned aircraft cooperative combat effectiveness based on AHP-fuzzy comprehensive judgment method[J]. Ship Electronic Countermeasures,2015,38(06):80-84+92.DOI:10.16426/j.cnki.jcdzdk.2015.06.019.

[30] WANG Tan, YANG Sen, QI Xiaohui, et al. Evaluation of manned aircraft/unmanned aircraft cooperative combat effectiveness based on Hopfield network[J]. Electro-Optics and Control,2021,28(10):80-84.

[31] MA Jiufang,YANG Sen,HUANG Xinxin. Evaluation of manned/unmanned cooperative combat effectiveness based on gray hierarchical analysis[J]. Telecommunications Technology, 2023, 63 (10): 1625-1630.DOI:10.20079/j.issn.1001-893x.230428001.

[32] HAN Yueming,LIU Tielin,XUE Hui. Evaluation of manned/unmanned aircraft cooperative combat effectiveness based on gray theory[J]. Military Operations Research and Evaluation, 2023, 38(01): 20-26.DOI:10.19949/j.ams.mora.20220711.01.

[33] WANG Guangyuan, SUN Tao, MAO Shichao, et al. Research on the assessment of operational effectiveness of manned aircraft/unmanned aircraft attacking the sea based on mission synergy[J]. Journal of Naval Aviation Engineering Institute,2017,32(05):491-495.

[34] LI Qi, WEI Xiaolong, LI Shenghou, et al. Object-element topological evaluation of manned aircraft/unmanned aircraft cooperative combat effectiveness[J]. Firepower and Command and Control,2024,49(05):9-17.

[35] ZHANG Wenbo,LI Xiaojun,LIU Bin. There are/UAV collaborative combat development status and combat utilization exploration[J]. Flying and navigation guide

[36] DING Dali, XIE Lei, WANG Yuan. Manned aircraft/unmanned aircraft cooperative combat utilization and impact on war patterns [J]. Unmanned Systems Technology, 2020, 3(04): 1-9.DOI:10.19942/j.issn.2096-5915.2020.04.001.

[37] WANG Qi, FENG Wei-Qiang, KONG Wei-Wei, et al. A preliminary study on cooperative control of surface manned/unmanned ships[J]. Ship Science and Technology,2024,46(17):127-131.

[38] SUN Shengzhi, SHENG Biqi, ZHANG Yuqiang, et al. Underwater cooperative operation mode and key technology[J]. Journal of Weapons and Equipment Engineering,2024,45(08):274-279.

[39] KOU Kunhu, WANG Yaping, SHANG Zaifei. Research on command and control system and cooperative mode of UAV for sea combat[J]. Firepower and Command and Control,2024,49(06):68-74.

[40] ZHAO Zhen, LIU Wenjun, LAN Xiaoping, et al. Research on rapid assessment method of combat effectiveness of manned/unmanned equipment system[J]. New Technology and New Process, 2024, (03): 39-43.DOI:10.16635/j.cnki.1003-5311.2024.03.006.

[41] Ning M ,Yunfeng C .Consensus-based distributed formation control for coordinated battle system of manned/unmanned aerial vehicles[J]. Transactions of the Institute of Measurement and Control, 2024, 46(1):3-14.

[42] Shulan Y ,Zhiwei H ,Hongbo C .Evaluation of vulnerability of MAV/UAV collaborative combat network based on complex network[J].Chaos, Solitons and Fractals: the interdisciplinary journal of Nonlinear Science, and Nonequilibrium and Complex Phenomena,2023,172

[43] HU Xueshun,ZENG Jinshu. Research on the development and utilization of manned/unmanned cooperative combat[C]//Chinese Institute of Command and Control (CICC). Proceedings of the 11th China Command and Control Conference. College of Information and Communication, National University of Defense Technology;,2023:4.DOI:10.26914/c.cnkihy.2023.043591.

[44] YE Kunwu,NIU Chao, LIU Zehua,et al. Human-machine relationship in intelligent air warfare [C]//Chinese Institute of Command and Control (CICC). Proceedings of the 11th China Command and Control Conference. Chinese People's Liberation Army Unit 93210; Beijing Institute of Technology;, 2023:6.DOI:10.26914/c.cnkihy.2023.043569.

[45] Intervention decision-making in MAV/UAV cooperative engagement based on human factors engineering[J].Journal of Systems Engineering and Electronics,2018,29(3):530-530.

[46] Liang X ,Xuanhong P ,Ming W .Analysis on manned/unmanned aerial vehicle cooperative operation in antisubmarine warfare[J].Zhongguo Jianchuan Yanjiu,2018,13(6):154-159.