Punitive Damages for Corporations in China: Establishment and improvement
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.54691/bcpssh.v21i.3631Keywords:
Punitive damages; Corporate Liability; Community Interest; Dual Remedy System.Abstract
Punitive damages are remedies for non-specific subjects like communities without specific rights suffering from illegal behaviors. Having the functions of compensation, punishment, and prevention, punitive damages are the necessary solution to the inherent deficiencies in current remedy system in China that both civil and public remedies can hardly cover the losses of communities. However, punitive damages are misunderstood theoretically and practically in China. Traditional critics like caseload of courts, lack of procedural protections, ineffectiveness in punishment and deterrence, and overlapping in functions cannot deny the necessity of establishing punitive damages. Meanwhile, punitive damages in Chinese legal system cannot fit in with their functions, comparing with legal practice in the US. This issue is mainly the result of the inadequate application conditions, narrow scope of factors, and single distribution of damages, which are also the issues to be resolved when reconstructing the punitive damages system. Based on legal analysis of positive law and judicial practice in both America and China, this article attempts to justify the necessity of punitive damages as well as putting forward some approaches to the reconstruction of punitive damages in China.
Downloads
References
Civil Code of the People's Republic of China (2020).
Law of the People's Republic of China on the Protection of Consumer Rights and Interests (2013).
Food Safety Law of the People's Republic of China (2009).
Li Yougen. A Study on Chines model of Punitive Damages [J]. Law and Social Development. 2015, 21(6): 109 - 126.
Yang Lixin. The New Development of Punitive Damages for Consumer Protection in China [J]. The Jurist. 2014 (2): 78 - 90.
Wang Liming. A Study of Punitive Damage [J]. Social Sciences in China. 2000 (4): 112 - 122.
Gao Zhihong. A System of Dual Punitive Damages and the Standardization in Its Operation [J]. Journal of Comparative Law. 2020 (6): 185 - 198.
Restatement (Second) of Torts (1979).
Civil Procedure Law of the People's Republic of China (2021).
Zhang Weiping. Civil Procedural Law [M]. Law Press, 2019.
Liu Yijun. Qualification of Plaintiff in Disputes of Fake Propaganda and Unfair Competition [J]. People’s Judicature (Case). 2018 (05): 91 - 96.
Tan Binglin. The Deterrence Logic of the Setting of Administrative Fines and Its Systematization [J]. Global Law Review. 2021(02): 22 - 38.
The Administrative Litigation Law of the People's Republic of China (2017).
Fu Liqing. The issue of the Definiteness and Generality of Criminal Law Terms: Focusing on the Criminal Legislative Technique [J]. Science of Law (Journal of Northwest University of Political Science and Law). 2013 (02): 93 - 101.
Criminal Law of the People's Republic of China (2020).
Law of The People's Republic of China on Administrative Penalty (2021).
Measures for the Implementation of Separation of Penalty Decisions from Collection of Penalty Payments (1997).
Measures for the Administration of Fines and Confiscated Property (2020).
Huang Wei. People's Republic of China Civil Tort Liability Code Reading (Chinese Edition) [M]. China Legal Publishing House, 2020.
Zhu Guangxin. Punitive Damages in China: Evolution and Application [J]. Social Sciences in China, 2015, 36 (3): 30 - 45.
Zhang Xinbao, Li Qian. Legislative Choice of Punitive Damages [J]. Tsinghua Law Review, 2009 (4): 5 - 20.
Zhang Qinyu. New Rights and Obligations——A Discussion from the Perspective of Group Rights [J]. Thinking, 2021, 47 (1): 144 - 151.
Lei Lei. The Criteria for Justifying Emerging (New) Rights [J]. Legal Forum, 2019, 34 (3): 20 - 29.
Jiang Wuzhen, Li Sheng. Legal Protection of Whole Social Interest——Analysis of the Foundation Domain of Economic Law [J]. Law Science (Journal of Northwest University of Politics and Law), 2005, 23 (1): 45 - 53.
Zhao Peng. Reflection on Punitive Damages from the Perspective of Administrative Law [J]. Chinese Journal of Law, 2019, 41 (1): 41 - 55.
Ying Feihu. Prohibition or Restriction: Study on Regulation of Buying Fake on Purpose [J]. Law Review. 2019, 37 (04): 63 - 78.
He Shan. The People's Republic of China Consumer Protection Law Interpretation and Practical Guide [M]. China Democracy Legal System Publishing House, 2013.
Xiong Bingwan. Formalism and Functionalism in Legal Reasoning an Exemplary Study of Punitive Damages for Intentional Purchasers of Defective Products [J]. Peking University Law Journal, 2017, 29 (02): 300 - 339.
Liu Zhiyang. Substantive and Procedural Justice in the Punitive Damages [J]. Law and Social Development, 2022, 163 (1): 212 - 224.
Some Provisions of the Supreme People's Court on Evidence in Civil Procedures (2019).
Criminal Procedure Law of the People's Republic of China (2018).
Liu Xiaomin, Zhang Bing. Questions on Punishment Damages——Comments on Article 47 of Tort Law [J]. Legal Forum, 2015, 30 (2): 70 - 83.
Huang Zhongshun. On the Consumer Public Interest Litigation with Punitive Damages [J]. Chinese Legal Science, 2020 (1): 260 - 282.
Yang Huixin. A Study on the Source of Rights for Punitive Damages in Public Interest Litigation [J]. Journal of Comparative Law, 2021 (4): 115 - 127.
Zhu Guangxin. Punitive Damages in the United States [J]. Journal of Comparative Law, 2022 (3): 152 - 168.
Helmut Koziol, Vanessa Wilcox. Punitive Damages: Common Law and Civil Law Perspectives [M]. Springer, 2009.
Ma Xinyan, Deng Bingning. The Fill in Function of Punishing Payment to Damage: On the Enlightenment of American System of Punishing Payment in the Law of Rights Violation [J]. Jilin University Journal Social Sciences Edition, 2012, 52 (03): 117 - 126.
Guangdong Consumer Council. v. Li Huawen, Chen Baocai, Liu Qiujin, Lai Dacheng, Li Hengcheng, Ye Tiaobin et, al., Shenzhen City Intermediate People’s Court of Guangdong Province Case No. 547 (2017), December 19, 2017.
Model Punitive Damages Act section (1996).
Pacific Mutual Life Insurance Company, Petitioner. v. Cleopatra Haslip et al, U.S. Supreme Court 499 U.S. 1, 4 March 1991, https://www.law.cornell.edu/supremecourt/text/499/1, 2022/9/30.
Gu Ming’an, Liang Tian. Viewing the Perfection of the System of Punitive Damages from the “Civil Code” [J]. Journal of Southwest Minzu University (Humanities and Social Science), 2021, 42 (3): 97 - 104.
Cao Weiwei. Judicial Remedy of Equal Right to Employment in the Transitional Period of Population Policy [J]. Law Science, 2022 (6): 175 - 192.
Copyright Law of the People's Republic of China (2020).
Interpretation of the Supreme People's Court on the Application of Punitive Damages in the Trial of Cases of Disputes over Ecological Environment Tort (2022).
Environmental Protection Law of the People's Republic of China (2014).
Fuliang County People’s Procuratorate of Jingdezhen City, Jiangxi Province. v. A Chemical Group Co., Ltd., Fuliang County People’s Court of Jiangxi Province Case No. 796(2020), January 4, 2021.
Interpretation of the Supreme People's Court on Problems regarding the Ascertainment of Compensation Liability for Emotional Damages in Civil Torts (2020).
Yang Huixin. A Study on the Source of Rights for Punitive Damages in Public Interest Litigation [J]. Journal of Comparative Law. 2021 (04): 115 - 127.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
How to Cite
