Research on the Effect of Executives as Audit Committee Members on Internal Control Weakness

Authors

  • Yange Li

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.54691/bcpbm.v14i.155

Keywords:

Listed companies; Audit committees; the dual roles of executives; internal control weakness.

Abstract

The Audit Committee is a specialized agency under the Board of Directors, and supervising the company's internal control is one of its duties. This article takes the 2012-2017 Shanghai-Shenzhen A-share non-financial listed company as a research sample, focusing on the chairmen, CEOs, CFOs, board secretaries and executive directors other than the CEO, discussing the impact of their concurrent appointment as audit committee members on the arising, correction and repair of internal control weakness in listed companies. The study found that different types of executives who are concurrently members of the audit committee would lead the internal control weakness to different directions. In general, excluding some less significant results, executives concurrently serve as members of the audit committee could stimulate the arising of internal control weakness and promote the correction and repair of the existing internal control weakness of the listed company. This indicates that when a listed company does not have internal control weakness, its executive layer intervention will weaken the effectiveness of the audit committee's governance and induce the arising of internal control weakness. Conversely, when the company inherently has internal control weakness, the intervention will strengthen the effectiveness of the audit committee's governance, making the audit committee more effective in monitoring internal control weakness. In addition, an important finding is that the existence of the Secretary of the board among the members of the audit committee will limit the chairs’ role in promoting internal control deficiencies.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Kaplan S N. Top Executives, Turnover, and Firm Performance in Germany [J]. Journal of Law, Economics, and Organization, 1994.

Elron E. Top management teams within multinational corporations: Effects of cultural heterogeneity [J]. Leadership Quarterly, 1997, 8(4):393-412.

Hambrick D C, Mason P A. Upper Echelons: The Organization as a Reflection of Its Top Managers [J]. Academy of Management Review, 1984, 9(2):193-206.

Krishnan H A, Park D. Effects of Top Management Team Change on Performance in Downsized US Companies [J]. Management International Review, 1998.

Wang Fei, Zhang Xiaolin. Research on internationalization of enterprise top management team [J]. Research on technology, economy and management, 2005 (03): 32-33

Lin Junqing, Huang Zuhui, sun Yongxiang. Salary gap, corporate performance and governance structure in senior management team [J]. Economic research, 2003 (04): 31-40 + 92

Lu Haifan. Research on executive pay gap and corporate performance from the perspective of endogenous [J]. Soft science, 2009,23 (12): 22-29

Zhang Ming, Chen Zhen. Empirical Study on implicit incentive of executive compensation [J]. Financial research, 2006 (03): 56-63

Ashbaugh-Skaife H, Collins D W, Kinney W R. The discovery and reporting of internal control deficiencies prior to SOX-mandated audits [J]. Journal of Accounting and Economics, 2007, 44(1-2):0-192.

Yang Youhong, Li Yuli. Identification, identification and reporting of internal control defects [J]. Accounting research, 2011 (03): 76-80

Li Yuli. Technical route for identification and identification of internal control defects -- Analysis from the perspective of management [J]. Journal of Central South University of economics and law, 2012 (03): 113-119

Fang Hongxing, Jin Yuna. Corporate governance, internal control and inefficient investment: theoretical analysis and empirical evidence [J]. Accounting research, 2013 (7): 63-69

Tian Juan, Yu Yumiao. Problems and Countermeasures in identification and identification of internal control defects [J]. Management world, 2012 (6): 180-181

Masli A, Peters G F, Richardson V J, et al. Examining the Potential Benefits of Internal Control Monitoring Technology [J]. The Accounting Review, 2010, 85(3):1001-1034.

Jeong-Bon Kim V, Song Byron Y, Zhang L. Internal Control Weakness and Bank Loan Contracting: Evidence from SOX Section 404 Disclosures [J]. The Accounting Review, 2011, 86(4):1157-1188.

Wang Qian, Dai Wentao. Prediction of major defects in internal control based on discriminant analysis [J]. Research on financial issues, 2012 (5)

Chen WuChao. Identification and disclosure of major defects in internal control of Listed Companies in the United States and their reference to Chinese enterprises [J]. Audit research, 2012 (01): 103-109

Boritz J E, Hayes L, Lim J H. A content analysis of auditors’ reports on IT internal control weaknesses: The comparative advantages of an automated approach to control weakness identification [J]. International Journal of Accounting Information Systems, 2013, 14(2):138–163.

Wang Hailin. Research on identification and diagnosis of enterprise internal control defects -- Model Construction Based on neural network [J]. Accounting research, 2017 (8): 74-80,95

Ge, W, Mcvy, S. The Disclosure of Material Weakness in Internal Control after the Sarbanes-Oxley Act. Accounting Horizons, 2005, 19(3): 137-158.

Doyle, J, Ge, W, Mcvay, S. Determinants of Weaknesses in Internal Control over Financial Reporting. Journal of Accounting and Economics, 2007, 44(1-2): 193-223.

Qi Baobao, Tian Gaoliang. Research on Influencing Factors of internal control defect disclosure of financial report -- An Empirical Analysis Based on Listed Companies in Shenzhen [J]. Journal of Shanxi University of Finance and economics, 2010 (04)

Research group of Institute of accounting and finance, Nanjing University. On the realistic model of Chinese enterprise internal control evaluation system -- a study based on 112 enterprise cases [J]. Accounting research, 2010 (6)

Shan Huajun. Data analysis and policy suggestions on internal control defects of Listed Companies [J]. Business accounting, 2010 (13): 45-46

Li Wanfu, Lin bin, Liu Chunli. How does the heterogeneity of internal control defects affect financial reporting——Empirical evidence based on Chinese context [J]. Financial research, 2014,40 (6)

Shi Yiru. Identification of internal control defects by trisection method [J]. Monthly journal of Finance and accounting, 2012 (14): 8-11

Lin Jing, Su Jinxiang. Determination of internal control defects -- Research Based on COSO’s new internal control framework [J]. Financial and accounting communication, 2016 (12)

Wu Yuxin. Audit Committee -- an important institutional arrangement in the internal control of Listed Companies [J]. Audit and economic research, 2003,18 (1): 27-29

Xie Deren. Audit Committee: original nature and action mechanism [J]. Accounting research, 2005 (9): 69-74

Qiao Chunhua. Scientific orientation of China’s Audit Committee [J]. Audit research, 2003 (6): 31-33

Qian Hua. Research on the relationship between Audit Committee and internal audit [J]. Audit and economic research, 2006,21 (6): 49-51

Wu Qinghua, Wang Pingxin, Yin Junming. Characteristics of audit committee and board of directors and financial reporting quality -- An Empirical Study Based on China’s securities market [J]. Management review, 2006,18 (7): 49-56

Zhu Jinyu, Hu Chunhui, Yi Ting. The essential attribute and institutional innovation of Audit Committee -- from the perspective of new institutional economics [J]. Audit and economic research, 2009,24 (4): 3-11

Xie Deren. Audit committee system and Governance Innovation of Chinese Listed Companies [J]. Accounting research, 2006 (7): 39-44

Qiao Chunhua, Jiang Suya. Discussion on some theoretical issues of Audit Committee [J]. Audit research, 2008 (2)

Chen Cheng, Liu Jianmin. Review on the impact of Audit Committee on internal control [J]. Friends of accounting, 2013 (2): 62-64

Abdolmohammadi M J, Shanteau J. Personal attributes of expert auditors [J]. Organizational Behavior & Human Decision Processes, 1992, 53(2):158-172.

Wolnizer P W. Are Audit Committees Red Herrings? [J]. Abacus, 1995, 31(1):22.

Dezoort F T. An analysis of experience effects on audit committee members’ oversight judgments [J]. Accounting Organizations & Society, 1998, 23(1):1-21.

Yang Zhonglian, Xu Zhengdan. Empirical Study on the motivation of Chinese companies to establish audit committees [J]. Audit research, 2004 (1): 19-24

Huang Rongbing, Wang Yuetang. Internal control from the perspective of Corporate Governance -- Analysis Based on the Audit Committee [J]. Journal of Central South University of economics and law, 2009 (1): 100-105

Chen Jiaxi, Wang Liyan. Research on domestic audit committee: ten-year review and prospect (2002-2011) [J]. Audit research, 2012 (04): 61-67

Zhou Shouhua, Hu Weimin, Lin bin, et al. Research on internal control of Chinese Listed Companies in 2012[J]. Accounting research, 2013 (7): 3-12,96

Harris M, Raviv A. A Theory of Board Control and Size [J]. Review of Financial Studies, 2008, 21(4):1797-1832.

Beng Wee Goh. Audit Committees, Boards of Directors, and Remediation of Material Weaknesses in Internal Control [J]. Contemporary Accounting Research, 2008, 26(2).

Yang Ling. Empirical Study on the relationship between management characteristics and internal control defects of Listed Companies[D].2015

Hoitash R, Hoitash U, Johnstone K M. Internal Control Material Weaknesses and CFO Compensation [J]. Contemporary Accounting Research, 2012, 29(3):0-0.

Mitra S, Hossain M, Marks B R. Corporate ownership characteristics and timeliness of remediation of internal control weaknesses [J]. Managerial Auditing Journal, 2012, 27(9):846 - 877.

Wan Peng, Qu Xiaohui. Voluntary disclosure of chairman’s personal characteristics, agency costs and revenue plans -- Empirical Evidence from Shanghai and Shenzhen Listed Companies [J]. Accounting research, 2012 (7): 15-23

Zhang Yang. Research on the correlation between the characteristics of the board of directors of Chinese listed companies and the effectiveness of internal control [D]. Northwest University, 2013

Liu Zuji. Research on Influencing Factors of enterprise internal control effectiveness [D]. Institute of financial science, Ministry of finance, 2013

Zhao Xi, Xu Ningning. Management power, opportunistic motivation and internal control defect information disclosure [J]. Audit research, 2013 (04): 101-109

Liu Qiliang, Luo Le, Zhang yaman, et al. Executive centralization, internal control and accounting information quality[J]. Nankai management review, 2013,16 (1): 15-23

Zhou Lan, he Anyi, Li Zhijun. Research on the governance effect of internal control defect disclosure of Listed Companies in China -- An Empirical Analysis Based on the leadership structure of the board of directors [J]. Journal of Yunnan University of Finance and economics, 2014,30 (03): 141-146

Guo Jun, Zhao Xi. Defects in board governance, executive power and internal control [J]. Soft science, 2015,29 (4): 43-47

Zhang Li, Li Wenchang. Impact of chairman characteristics on internal control defects [J]. Financial and accounting communication, 2018 (5): 37-42

Zahra, S, Pearce, J. Boards of Directors and corporate financial performance: A Review and Integrative Model [J]. Journal of Management.1989, (15):291-334.

Menon K, Williams J D. The use of audit committees for monitoring [J]. Journal of Accounting & Public Policy, 1994, 13(2):121-139.

Hoitash U, Hoitash R, Bedard J C. Corporate Governance and Internal Control over Financial Reporting: A Comparison of Regulatory Regimes [J]. Accounting Review, 2009, 84(3):839-867.

Wang Yuetang, Tu Jianming. An Empirical Study on the governance effectiveness of audit committees of Listed Companies -- Empirical Evidence from Shanghai and Shenzhen stock markets [J]. Management world, 2006 (11): 135-143

Xie Yongzhen. Empirical Study on governance efficiency of audit committees of Listed Companies in China [J]. Nankai management review, 2006,9 (1): 66-73

Dong Huina, Zhu Zhixiong. Impact of audit committee characteristics on internal control defects of Listed Companies [J]. Journal of Shanxi University of Finance and economics, 2012,34 (1): 114-124

Ding Peiwen. Research on the impact of board governance structure on enterprise internal control [J]. Financial economy, 2014 (11): 130-132

Liu Yan, Yao Haixin. Executive power, audit committee professionalism and internal control defects [J]. Nankai management review, 2014,17 (02): 4-12

Chen Hanwen, Wang Weicheng. Chairman characteristics, salary level and internal control [J]. Journal of Xiamen University (PHILOSOPHY AND SOCIAL SCIENCES EDITION), 2014 (2): 90-99

Bebchuk L A, Fried J M, Walker D I. Managerial Power and Rent Extraction in the Design of Executive Compensation [J]. University of Chicago Law Review, 2002, 69(3):751-846.

Cohen J R, Hoitash U, Krishnamoorthy G, et al. The effect of audit committee industry expertise on monitoring the financial reporting process [J]. Social Science Electronic Publishing, 2014, 89(1):243-273.

Wang Shouhai, Li Yun. Management intervention, independence of audit committee and earnings management [J]. Audit research, 2012 (04): 68-75

Badolato P G, Donelson D C, Ege M. Audit committee financial expertise and earnings management: The role of status[J]. Journal of Accounting & Economics, 2015, 58(2-3): 208-230.

Lisic L L, Neal T L, Zhang I X, et al. CEO Power, Internal Control Quality, and Audit Committee Effectiveness in Substance Versus in Form[J]. Contemporary Accounting Research, 2016, 33(3):1199-1237.

Hong Jianqiao, Fang Junxiong. Audit committee system and improvement of earnings quality [J]. Nankai management review, 2009,12 (4): 107-112

Li Yun, Wang Feifei, Yin Tianxiang. CEO power, audit committee professionalism and audit fees [J]. Audit research, 2017 (06): 91-98

Pan Jun, Yu Yumiao. The performance ability of the audit committee, the influence of the chairman and the quality of the company’s financial report [J]. Nankai management review, 2017,20 (1): 108-118

Zhang Chuan, Huang Xiayan. Audit committee power erosion, management incentive and earnings quality [J]. Audit and economic research, 2018 (3)

Tian Gaoliang, Qi Baolei, Li liuchuang. Research on Influencing Factors of internal control defect Disclosure Based on financial reporting. Nankai management review, 2010,13 (4): 134-141

Zhu Caijie, Liu changcui. Research on the correlation between corporate governance and internal control defect repair -- empirical data from state-owned listed companies from 2010 to 2014[J]. Audit research, 2017 (4): 97-105

Downloads

Published

2021-11-24